Paper · 2019 · Bangladesh Rice Journal

Screening Rice Germplasm against Sheath Blight Disease of Rice and its Integrated Management in Bangladesh

S Parveen; MA Ali; MA Ali

20
claims
47
verbatim quotes
5
citations
2
research areas
✓
Open access

Abstract

Fifty-seven rice germplasm collected from BRRI Genebank were screened against sheath blight (ShB) by artificial inoculation in field and laboratory conditions in T. Aman 2012. Significant differences on relation to lesion height (RLH) among the germplasm were observed, where the highest (83%) was recorded in susceptible check, BR11 and the lowest (8.33%) was in Orgoja. Severity score of ShB was recorded maximum (9) in Dudhsail, Basi, Chaula mari, Holdemota, Calendamota, Semmua, Kotijira, Halisail, Horakani, Kalisura, Ashfuli, Huglapata and BR11 as highly susceptible to ShB, whereas it was minimum (1) in Orgoja. Gopal ghosh was observed as moderately tolerant with 27.33% RLH and severity score 3, while Kala binni, Khazur chari, Binni, Kalagora, Patjait and Dorkumur found moderately tolerant with severity score 5. In detached sheath inoculation method in test tube, most of the germplasms found highly susceptible, except Orgoja as resistant and Gopal ghosh as moderately tolerant. However, Orgoja showed resistance in both field inoculation and detached sheath inoculation methods. But, Dorkumur was found moderately tolerant in field and highly susceptible in detached sheath inoculation in laboratory. The experiment of Integrated Disease Management (IDM) packages was conducted in the farmer’s field with BR11 at Fulpur, Mymensingh during T. Aman 2013. The IDM practices of rice ShB resulted profound effect. Relative lesion height, percent disease index, tiller infection and hill infection were maximum (68%, 69%, 86% and 79% respectively) in T6 (control) and minimum in T1 [FDR (removal of floating debris) + 30 July transplanting + Potash (K) fertilizer (202 g decimal-1) + Top dressing of urea (247 kg ha-1) in four equal splits at 15 days interval + single spray of fungicides of Azoxystrobin 10% (0.17 kg ha-1) + Tebuconazole 90% (500 ml ha-1)]. Moreover, the highest number of panicles per m2, filled grains per panicle and grains yield were recorded in T1 (160, 150 and 6.25 t ha-1 respectively) and the minimum in T6 (227, 120 and 3.6 t ha-1 respectively). Therefore, the best IDM package was T1 for its effective control of ShB disease as well as yield maximization of rice. Finally, Orgoja could be used in resistance breeding for varietal improvement and the IDM package of T1 need to be recommended to prescribe in the farmer’s field after simulation in different AEZs and seasons with different varieties of Bangladesh. Bangladesh Rice j. 2018, 22(2): 1-12

Abstract from the paper’s OpenAlex record, shown for indexing and research. Copyright remains with the authors or the publisher. Read at the source ↗

The text the model read, with the source record’s inline markup (italics, sub- and superscripts) rendered and its character entities decoded; quote offsets refer to the raw text.

Claims 20

Observationobservedoriginal resultsignificant (as stated)measured

Claim · model-written summary

Relation to lesion height differed significantly among the rice germplasm.

Material
rice germplasme0
Outcome
relation to lesion height (RLH)e1

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Oryza sativa
Oryza sativa · Taxon · picture from its Wikimedia Commons categoryDesmanthus4food · CC BY-SA 3.0 us · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“Fifty-seven rice germplasm collected from BRRI Genebank”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 0–55 · show in text ↑
e1

“Significant differences on relation to lesion height (RLH) among the germplasm were observed, where the highest (83%) was recorded in susceptible check, BR11 and the lowest (8.33%) was in Orgoja”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 176–370 · show in text ↑
Observationobservedoriginal resultnegativemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

BR11, the susceptible check, had the highest relation to lesion height (83%).

Material
BR11e1
Outcome
relation to lesion height (RLH)e1
Direction
higheste1
Value
83%e1
Qualifier
susceptible checke1

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Oryza sativa
Oryza sativa · Taxon · picture from its Wikimedia Commons categoryDesmanthus4food · CC BY-SA 3.0 us · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“Fifty-seven rice germplasm collected from BRRI Genebank”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 0–55 · show in text ↑
e1

“Significant differences on relation to lesion height (RLH) among the germplasm were observed, where the highest (83%) was recorded in susceptible check, BR11 and the lowest (8.33%) was in Orgoja”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 176–370 · show in text ↑
Observationobservedoriginal resultpositivemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Orgoja had the lowest relation to lesion height (8.33%).

Material
Orgojae1
Outcome
relation to lesion height (RLH)e1
Direction
loweste1
Value
8.33%e1

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Oryza sativa
Oryza sativa · Taxon · picture from its Wikimedia Commons categoryDesmanthus4food · CC BY-SA 3.0 us · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“Fifty-seven rice germplasm collected from BRRI Genebank”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 0–55 · show in text ↑
e1

“Significant differences on relation to lesion height (RLH) among the germplasm were observed, where the highest (83%) was recorded in susceptible check, BR11 and the lowest (8.33%) was in Orgoja”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 176–370 · show in text ↑
Observationobservedoriginal resultnegativemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Thirteen germplasm including BR11 had the maximum severity score of 9 and were highly susceptible to sheath blight.

Material
Dudhsail, Basi, Chaula mari, Holdemota, Calendamota, Semmua, Kotijira, Halisail, Horakani, Kalisura, Ashfuli, Huglapata and BR11e2
Outcome
Severity score of ShBe2
Direction
maximume2
Value
9e2

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Oryza sativa
Oryza sativa · Taxon · picture from its Wikimedia Commons categoryDesmanthus4food · CC BY-SA 3.0 us · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“Fifty-seven rice germplasm collected from BRRI Genebank”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 0–55 · show in text ↑
e2

“Severity score of ShB was recorded maximum (9) in Dudhsail, Basi, Chaula mari, Holdemota, Calendamota, Semmua, Kotijira, Halisail, Horakani, Kalisura, Ashfuli, Huglapata and BR11 as highly susceptible to ShB, whereas it was minimum (1) in Orgoja”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 372–617 · show in text ↑
Observationobservedoriginal resultpositivemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Orgoja had the minimum severity score of 1.

Material
Orgojae2
Outcome
Severity score of ShBe2
Direction
minimume2
Value
1e2

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Oryza sativa
Oryza sativa · Taxon · picture from its Wikimedia Commons categoryDesmanthus4food · CC BY-SA 3.0 us · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“Fifty-seven rice germplasm collected from BRRI Genebank”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 0–55 · show in text ↑
e2

“Severity score of ShB was recorded maximum (9) in Dudhsail, Basi, Chaula mari, Holdemota, Calendamota, Semmua, Kotijira, Halisail, Horakani, Kalisura, Ashfuli, Huglapata and BR11 as highly susceptible to ShB, whereas it was minimum (1) in Orgoja”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 372–617 · show in text ↑
Observationobservedoriginal resultpositivemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Gopal ghosh had a relation to lesion height of 27.33% and was moderately tolerant.

Material
Gopal ghoshe3
Outcome
RLHe3
Value
27.33%e3
Qualifier
moderately tolerante3

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Oryza sativa
Oryza sativa · Taxon · picture from its Wikimedia Commons categoryDesmanthus4food · CC BY-SA 3.0 us · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“Fifty-seven rice germplasm collected from BRRI Genebank”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 0–55 · show in text ↑
e3

“Gopal ghosh was observed as moderately tolerant with 27.33% RLH and severity score 3”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 619–703 · show in text ↑
Observationobservedoriginal resultpositivemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Gopal ghosh had a severity score of 3.

Material
Gopal ghoshe3
Outcome
severity scoree3
Value
3e3

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Oryza sativa
Oryza sativa · Taxon · picture from its Wikimedia Commons categoryDesmanthus4food · CC BY-SA 3.0 us · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“Fifty-seven rice germplasm collected from BRRI Genebank”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 0–55 · show in text ↑
e3

“Gopal ghosh was observed as moderately tolerant with 27.33% RLH and severity score 3”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 619–703 · show in text ↑
Observationobservedoriginal resultpositivemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Six germplasm were moderately tolerant with a severity score of 5.

Material
Kala binni, Khazur chari, Binni, Kalagora, Patjait and Dorkumure4
Outcome
severity scoree4
Value
5e4
Qualifier
moderately tolerante4

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Oryza sativa
Oryza sativa · Taxon · picture from its Wikimedia Commons categoryDesmanthus4food · CC BY-SA 3.0 us · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“Fifty-seven rice germplasm collected from BRRI Genebank”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 0–55 · show in text ↑
e4

“Kala binni, Khazur chari, Binni, Kalagora, Patjait and Dorkumur found moderately tolerant with severity score 5”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 711–822 · show in text ↑
Observationobservedoriginal resultmixedmeasured

Claim · model-written summary

In detached sheath inoculation in a test tube, most germplasm were highly susceptible, except Orgoja (resistant) and Gopal ghosh (moderately tolerant).

Outcome
highly susceptiblee5
Qualifier
except Orgoja as resistant and Gopal ghosh as moderately tolerante5
Setting
test tubee5

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Oryza sativa
Oryza sativa · Taxon · picture from its Wikimedia Commons categoryDesmanthus4food · CC BY-SA 3.0 us · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“Fifty-seven rice germplasm collected from BRRI Genebank”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 0–55 · show in text ↑
e5

“In detached sheath inoculation method in test tube, most of the germplasms found highly susceptible, except Orgoja as resistant and Gopal ghosh as moderately tolerant”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 824–990 · show in text ↑
Observationobservedoriginal resultpositivemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Orgoja showed resistance in both field inoculation and detached sheath inoculation.

Material
Orgojae6
Outcome
resistancee6
Setting
field inoculation and detached sheath inoculation methodse6

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Oryza sativa
Oryza sativa · Taxon · picture from its Wikimedia Commons categoryDesmanthus4food · CC BY-SA 3.0 us · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“Fifty-seven rice germplasm collected from BRRI Genebank”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 0–55 · show in text ↑
e6

“Orgoja showed resistance in both field inoculation and detached sheath inoculation methods”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 1001–1091 · show in text ↑
Observationobservedoriginal resultmixedmeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Dorkumur was moderately tolerant in the field but highly susceptible in detached sheath inoculation in the laboratory.

Material
Dorkumure7
Outcome
highly susceptiblee7
Qualifier
moderately tolerant in fielde7
Setting
laboratorye7

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Oryza sativa
Oryza sativa · Taxon · picture from its Wikimedia Commons categoryDesmanthus4food · CC BY-SA 3.0 us · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“Fifty-seven rice germplasm collected from BRRI Genebank”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 0–55 · show in text ↑
e7

“Dorkumur was found moderately tolerant in field and highly susceptible in detached sheath inoculation in laboratory”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 1098–1213 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultpositivemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Under the IDM package T1, relative lesion height was minimum, versus 68% in the T6 control.

Treatment
Integrated Disease Management (IDM) packagese2
Outcome
Relative lesion heighte1
Direction
minimume1
Value
68%e1
Comparator
T6 (control)e1
Setting
Fulpur, Mymensinghe2

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Oryza sativa
Oryza sativa · Taxon · picture from its Wikimedia Commons categoryDesmanthus4food · CC BY-SA 3.0 us · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“Fifty-seven rice germplasm collected from BRRI Genebank”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 0–55 · show in text ↑
e1

“Relative lesion height, percent disease index, tiller infection and hill infection were maximum (68%, 69%, 86% and 79% respectively) in T6 (control) and minimum in T1”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 1423–1589 · show in text ↑
e2

“The experiment of Integrated Disease Management (IDM) packages was conducted in the farmer’s field with BR11 at Fulpur, Mymensingh during T. Aman 2013”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 1215–1365 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultpositivemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Under the IDM package T1, percent disease index was minimum, versus 69% in the T6 control.

Treatment
Integrated Disease Management (IDM) packagese2
Outcome
percent disease indexe1
Direction
minimume1
Value
69%e1
Comparator
T6 (control)e1

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Oryza sativa
Oryza sativa · Taxon · picture from its Wikimedia Commons categoryDesmanthus4food · CC BY-SA 3.0 us · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“Fifty-seven rice germplasm collected from BRRI Genebank”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 0–55 · show in text ↑
e1

“Relative lesion height, percent disease index, tiller infection and hill infection were maximum (68%, 69%, 86% and 79% respectively) in T6 (control) and minimum in T1”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 1423–1589 · show in text ↑
e2

“The experiment of Integrated Disease Management (IDM) packages was conducted in the farmer’s field with BR11 at Fulpur, Mymensingh during T. Aman 2013”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 1215–1365 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultpositivemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Under the IDM package T1, tiller infection was minimum, versus 86% in the T6 control.

Treatment
Integrated Disease Management (IDM) packagese2
Outcome
tiller infectione1
Direction
minimume1
Value
86%e1
Comparator
T6 (control)e1

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Oryza sativa
Oryza sativa · Taxon · picture from its Wikimedia Commons categoryDesmanthus4food · CC BY-SA 3.0 us · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“Fifty-seven rice germplasm collected from BRRI Genebank”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 0–55 · show in text ↑
e1

“Relative lesion height, percent disease index, tiller infection and hill infection were maximum (68%, 69%, 86% and 79% respectively) in T6 (control) and minimum in T1”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 1423–1589 · show in text ↑
e2

“The experiment of Integrated Disease Management (IDM) packages was conducted in the farmer’s field with BR11 at Fulpur, Mymensingh during T. Aman 2013”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 1215–1365 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultpositivemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Under the IDM package T1, hill infection was minimum, versus 79% in the T6 control.

Treatment
Integrated Disease Management (IDM) packagese2
Outcome
hill infectione1
Direction
minimume1
Value
79%e1
Comparator
T6 (control)e1

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Oryza sativa
Oryza sativa · Taxon · picture from its Wikimedia Commons categoryDesmanthus4food · CC BY-SA 3.0 us · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“Fifty-seven rice germplasm collected from BRRI Genebank”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 0–55 · show in text ↑
e1

“Relative lesion height, percent disease index, tiller infection and hill infection were maximum (68%, 69%, 86% and 79% respectively) in T6 (control) and minimum in T1”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 1423–1589 · show in text ↑
e2

“The experiment of Integrated Disease Management (IDM) packages was conducted in the farmer’s field with BR11 at Fulpur, Mymensingh during T. Aman 2013”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 1215–1365 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultpositivemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Under the IDM package T1, the number of panicles per m2 was highest (160) versus 227 in T6.

Treatment
Integrated Disease Management (IDM) packagese2
Outcome
number of panicles per m2e3
Direction
higheste3
Value
160e3
Comparator
T6e3

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Oryza sativa
Oryza sativa · Taxon · picture from its Wikimedia Commons categoryDesmanthus4food · CC BY-SA 3.0 us · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“Fifty-seven rice germplasm collected from BRRI Genebank”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 0–55 · show in text ↑
e2

“The experiment of Integrated Disease Management (IDM) packages was conducted in the farmer’s field with BR11 at Fulpur, Mymensingh during T. Aman 2013”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 1215–1365 · show in text ↑
e3

“Moreover, the highest number of panicles per m2, filled grains per panicle and grains yield were recorded in T1 (160, 150 and 6.25 t ha-1 respectively) and the minimum in T6 (227, 120 and 3.6 t ha-1 respectively)”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 1867–2079 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultpositivemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Under the IDM package T1, filled grains per panicle were highest (150) versus 120 in T6.

Treatment
Integrated Disease Management (IDM) packagese2
Outcome
filled grains per paniclee3
Direction
higheste3
Value
150e3
Comparator
T6e3

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Oryza sativa
Oryza sativa · Taxon · picture from its Wikimedia Commons categoryDesmanthus4food · CC BY-SA 3.0 us · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“Fifty-seven rice germplasm collected from BRRI Genebank”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 0–55 · show in text ↑
e2

“The experiment of Integrated Disease Management (IDM) packages was conducted in the farmer’s field with BR11 at Fulpur, Mymensingh during T. Aman 2013”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 1215–1365 · show in text ↑
e3

“Moreover, the highest number of panicles per m2, filled grains per panicle and grains yield were recorded in T1 (160, 150 and 6.25 t ha-1 respectively) and the minimum in T6 (227, 120 and 3.6 t ha-1 respectively)”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 1867–2079 · show in text ↑
Intervention effectobservedoriginal resultpositivemeasured

Claim · model-written summary

Under the IDM package T1, grain yield was highest (6.25 t ha-1) versus 3.6 t ha-1 in T6.

Treatment
Integrated Disease Management (IDM) packagese2
Outcome
grains yielde3
Direction
higheste3
Value
6.25 t ha-1e3
Comparator
T6e3

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Oryza sativa
Oryza sativa · Taxon · picture from its Wikimedia Commons categoryDesmanthus4food · CC BY-SA 3.0 us · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“Fifty-seven rice germplasm collected from BRRI Genebank”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 0–55 · show in text ↑
e2

“The experiment of Integrated Disease Management (IDM) packages was conducted in the farmer’s field with BR11 at Fulpur, Mymensingh during T. Aman 2013”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 1215–1365 · show in text ↑
e3

“Moreover, the highest number of panicles per m2, filled grains per panicle and grains yield were recorded in T1 (160, 150 and 6.25 t ha-1 respectively) and the minimum in T6 (227, 120 and 3.6 t ha-1 respectively)”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 1867–2079 · show in text ↑
Recommendationauthor interpretationoriginal resultbasis n/a

Claim · model-written summary

The IDM package of T1 should be recommended to farmers after simulation across AEZs and seasons with different varieties.

Outcome
the IDM package of T1e4
Setting
farmer’s fielde4

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Oryza sativa
Oryza sativa · Taxon · picture from its Wikimedia Commons categoryDesmanthus4food · CC BY-SA 3.0 us · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“Fifty-seven rice germplasm collected from BRRI Genebank”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 0–55 · show in text ↑
e4

“the IDM package of T1 need to be recommended to prescribe in the farmer’s field after simulation in different AEZs and seasons with different varieties of Bangladesh”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 2282–2447 · show in text ↑
Recommendationauthor interpretationoriginal resultbasis n/a

Claim · model-written summary

Orgoja could be used in resistance breeding for varietal improvement.

Material
Orgojae5
Outcome
resistance breeding for varietal improvemente5

Organisms pictured · Representative pictures of the matched species, not figures from the paper.

Oryza sativa
Oryza sativa · Taxon · picture from its Wikimedia Commons categoryDesmanthus4food · CC BY-SA 3.0 us · Wikimedia Commons ↗

Verbatim

e0

“Fifty-seven rice germplasm collected from BRRI Genebank”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 0–55 · show in text ↑
e5

“Orgoja could be used in resistance breeding for varietal improvement”

✓ located verbatim in the source · abstract, characters 2209–2277 · show in text ↑

storage · disease · Oryza sativa (rice)Positive and negative results

12 papers: 6 positive, 6 negative or no effect

5 papers in the same direction as this paper · 6 in the opposite direction

  1. no effect
  2. no effect
  3. negative

8 papers more in this group

See all 12 papers →

storage · yield · Oryza sativa (rice)Positive and negative results

44 papers: 41 positive, 3 negative or no effect

40 papers in the same direction as this paper · 2 in the opposite direction · 1 reporting no difference from an alternative

  1. no effect
  2. no effect
  3. no effect

40 papers more in this group

See all 44 papers →

ipm · disease · Oryza sativa (rice)Results agree

11 papers: 11 positive, 0 negative or no effect

10 papers in the same direction as this paper

  1. positive
  2. positive
  3. positive

7 papers more in this group

See all 11 papers →

ipm · yield · Oryza sativa (rice)Results agree

43 papers: 43 positive, 0 negative or no effect

42 papers in the same direction as this paper

  1. positive
  2. positive
  3. positive

39 papers more in this group

See all 43 papers →

Claims are grouped by organism, treatment and what was measured or targeted. A paper counts as positive when any of its claims in the group is positive.